Review Guide

Every game we review gets a score from 1 to 10, in half-point steps. Here is what each score means.

10 · Legendary

Legitimate masterpieces that deserve your time, money, and attention. If you don’t play these games, we just might judge you. Actually scratch that, we will.

9 – 9.5 · Outstanding

Games with an abundance of strengths that succeed in almost every way. Only held back by small issues that barely impact the overall experience.

8 – 8.5 · Great

Impressive games that are absolutely worth playing but have problems that keep them from realizing their full potential.

7 – 7.5 · Good

Games with much more to love than hate, though some significant issues can hinder players’ experiences overall.

6 – 6.5 · Decent

Solid experiences mired by flaws but still have something special to offer to players.

5 – 5.5 · Average

Just mid. The good and bad qualities come in equal measure, and we recommend looking into these games more to see if they’re worth it for you.

4 – 4.5 · Weak

Frustrating games that have some positive aspects but are tough to get through because of an abundance of weaknesses.

3 – 3.5 · Poor

Not much good to be found in these games, and we would recommend skipping them in most circumstances.

2 – 2.5 · Bad

A waste of time, money and effort on the player’s part. Borders on unplayable with few or any redeeming qualities to be found.

1 – 1.5 · Avoid

Straight up trash. Don’t play it, and don’t say we didn’t warn you.